Mutual Respect and Common Ground Between Gandhi and BoseImportance 4/5
Which title did Gandhi give Bose in 1942? Which title did Bose give Gandhi, in what year, and in what kind of speech? Understand the views they shared despite their differences, on socialism, religion, communism, untouchability and women.
Non-Violence versus Militant ApproachImportance 3/5
Be able to explain Gandhi's two reasons for objecting to violence. Understand why Bose found non-violence inadequate, and what he thought civil disobedience could and could not achieve.
Means and Ends: Gandhi and BoseImportance 3/5
How did Bose justify seeking help from the Axis powers even though he disliked Nazi racialism? Be able to explain why Gandhi insisted that means must be as good as ends, and why he would not take advantage of Britain's difficulty. What did Bose say about Gandhi's methods in his Tokyo speech?
Bose's Views on Democracy and Authoritarian RuleImportance 3/5
How did Bose's view of democracy change over time? Remember the Tokyo University address of 1944. Learn when the Provisional Government of Azad Hind was proclaimed and which offices Bose held in it. What did he expect after an initial stage of authoritarian rule?
Samyavada and Bose's SocialismImportance 3/5
What did Bose combine in 1930 under the name 'samyavada'? Why was he neither a Nazi or Fascist nor a communist? Understand what he meant by being a "leftist" before and after independence.
Gandhi's Idea of the State (Hind Swaraj, Ramrajya, Village Republics)Importance 4/5UPSC 1996, 2020
Remember the work and year where Gandhi set out his political ideas. Understand his Ramrajya, why he feared the power of the state, and what he thought of party politics. What was his model of the village republic (its panchayat, its circles)? Why is he sometimes called an anarchist, and why did he put duties above rights?
Militarism: Bose and GandhiImportance 2/5
What attracted Bose to military discipline, and what display did he organise at a Congress session in Calcutta? Understand Gandhi's views on the causes of war, and on whether any military and any war can be justified.
Gandhi's Ideas on Economy (Trusteeship)Importance 4/5
Why did Gandhi reject both capitalism and Western socialism? Understand his picture of a decentralised village economy and village Sarvodaya. Remember his 1909 letter to Henry Polak. What was his position on machinery, and where did he draw the line? Be able to explain the theory of trusteeship.
Bose's Ideas on EconomyImportance 3/5
Understand why Bose saw economic freedom as the essence of other freedoms and how he linked modern agriculture to industry. Remember his economic proposals at Haripura and the Soviet example that impressed him. What reasons did he give for industrialisation, and how did he classify industry? What role did he give cottage industries?
Religion: Gandhi and BoseImportance 2/5
Understand how religion shaped Gandhi's ideas, how he saw different religions, and why he could not imagine a state without religion. Know the sources of Bose's spiritual outlook. How did his use of Hindu symbols fit with his non-sectarian stance, and how did the INA's practice show that stance? How did Gandhi's view of religion and the state differ from Bose's?
Caste and Untouchability: Gandhi and BoseImportance 3/5
What were Gandhi's three goals for society? He opposed untouchability, but what was his position on the varna system? Understand Bose's very different picture of a society without caste, and the influence of Vivekananda on it.
Gandhi's Views on WomenImportance 3/5
Why do scholars call the participation of women in the struggle Gandhi's most radical idea? Remember the social evils against women that he opposed. Understand the limits of his view of gender roles, and Judith Brown's assessment of his ideal woman.
Bose's Views on Women and Their Role in the INAImportance 4/5
Remember Bose's 1928 address on women's status and the separate body for women set up under his Congress presidency. In 1943, which women's regiment did he form in the INA, and who commanded it? Remember what he wanted for women in education, purdah and widow remarriage.
Gandhi on Education and His Basic Education SchemeImportance 4/5
What did Gandhi want in place of English as the medium of instruction, and what age group did he want free compulsory education for? Understand the difference he drew between literacy and education, and the place of morality in it. What was his scheme of basic education called, when did he conceive it, and what did it stress?
Bose on EducationImportance 2/5
Understand why Bose stressed technical and scientific education, and what plan he wanted for Indian students sent abroad.